‘Better Than Midsomer Murders?!’ Shakespeare & Hathaway Returns With Dark Twists, Cozy Crime, and a Cult Following That Won’t Let Go
When Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators first aired in 2018, few expected the quirky detective duo from Stratford-upon-Avon to become one of Britain’s most beloved exports in the crowded crime-drama genre. But here we are in September 2025: the show is back with its fifth season, an 89% Rotten Tomatoes score, and fans calling it “better than Midsomer Murders.” The hype is real, the mysteries darker, and the oddball chemistry between Jo Joyner and Mark Benton stronger than ever.
This is the season that could catapult the series from a cult favorite into the pantheon of iconic British detective dramas.
A Duo That Shouldn’t Work — But Does
At the heart of the series are two misfits who somehow make perfect sense together:
- Luella Shakespeare (Jo Joyner) — a warm-hearted ex-hairdresser who relies on instinct, charm, and compassion more than procedure.
- Frank Hathaway (Mark Benton) — a grumpy, down-on-his-luck ex-cop whose cynicism balances Lu’s optimism.
They are joined by their flamboyant assistant Sebastian Brudenell (Patrick Walshe McBride), who steals scenes with his theatrical flair and impeccable comedic timing.
The mismatched trio may not look like TV’s sharpest sleuths, but that’s exactly the point. Where most detective dramas lean on grit, violence, or high-concept gimmicks, Shakespeare & Hathaway thrives on wit, warmth, and the peculiar charm of ordinary people caught in extraordinary mysteries.
Season Five: A Darker Turn in the Shadows of Stratford
While the show is often described as “cosy crime,” Season 5 leans into its darker undercurrents without losing its humor. According to the BBC’s synopsis, Frank and Lu are reunited under tense circumstances after drifting apart. Their cases, once quirky diversions, now teeter on the edge of life-and-death stakes:
- A team-building retreat gone wrong ends with a client electrocuted in front of them.
- A Murder Mystery School Reunion traps the duo in an isolated mansion with a killer on the loose.
- Stratford’s annual “Horror-upon-Avon” convention turns deadly when a movie director is terrorized — and then murdered — by his own horror creations.
- Lu returns from holiday to find her house stolen, setting up one of the most personal and emotional investigations in the series.
Looming over all of this is a shadowy saboteur intent on destroying Shakespeare & Hathaway once and for all. As Frank, Lu, Sebastian, and their hacker ally Spider race against time, the season builds to a chilling climax that promises to be the most gripping finale yet.
The Guest Stars: A Who’s Who of British TV
The charm of Shakespeare & Hathaway has always been its guest stars — familiar faces from the best of British television. Season 5 is no exception, featuring:
- Christine Bottomley (Sherwood)
- Ciarán Griffiths (Coronation Street)
- Tanya Franks (Broadchurch)
- Kacey Ainsworth (Grantchester)
- Plus appearances from Guy Henry, Fiona Button, Matt Di Angelo, Emily Head, Jan Pearson, and many more.
The casting ensures each case feels fresh, with star power that keeps viewers guessing about who’s guilty, who’s innocent, and who’s hiding something in plain sight.
Cozy Crime, but With Bite
Critics often compare Shakespeare & Hathaway to Midsomer Murders or Death in Paradise, but fans insist it’s carved its own identity. Yes, there are picturesque settings and eccentric suspects, but the show’s blend of humor and humanity makes it stand apart.
Where Midsomer Murders can sometimes feel formulaic, Shakespeare & Hathaway leans into unpredictability. One moment you’re laughing at Sebastian in a Shakespearean costume, the next you’re holding your breath as Frank uncovers a betrayal that cuts too close to home.
That delicate balance between comedy and crime is what gives the show its addictive pull.
Why the Buzz Feels Bigger Than Ever
The return of Season 5 feels different — louder, more urgent, and more widely anticipated. Part of it comes from the show’s steady climb from sleeper hit to streaming sensation. Once tucked away on BBC daytime schedules, it now enjoys global exposure thanks to streaming platforms like Sky, Virgin Media, and NOW, where entire seasons can be devoured in one sitting.
The show’s 89% Rotten Tomatoes score hasn’t hurt either. International fans, especially in the U.S. and Australia, are calling it “the ultimate comfort watch” while also praising its surprisingly dark twists.
HELLO!’s Abby Allen summed it up:
“For fans of Midsomer Murders who want a mixture of comedy and crime, this is the perfect pick. With Jo Joyner and Mark Benton at the helm, it’s addictive television.”
The Secret Weapon: Chemistry
Joyner and Benton are no strangers to British TV audiences — she from Ackley Bridge and EastEnders, he from Waterloo Road and Northern Lights. But together, they’ve created something unexpected: a partnership that feels lived-in, messy, and authentic.
They bicker, they roll their eyes, they cover each other’s weaknesses, and occasionally, they even save each other’s lives. Theirs is not a romance — it’s something rarer on television: a genuine friendship between equals, tested and deepened by every case.
Add Sebastian into the mix, with his flamboyance and surprising resourcefulness, and you have one of TV’s most endearing detective trios.
Fans React: “Better Than Midsomer Murders?!”
Social media has been buzzing ever since the premiere date was announced. On Reddit threads and X (formerly Twitter), fans are already declaring Season 5 their most anticipated autumn binge:
- “The coziness of Midsomer with more laughs and sharper writing. Honestly, it’s better.”
- “Forget Nordic noir, this is English noir with a pint and a pun.”
- “Season 5 sounds darker and I’m here for it. Horror-upon-Avon? TAKE MY MONEY.”
A Saboteur in the Shadows
Perhaps the boldest move of Season 5 is its overarching storyline — the mysterious saboteur threatening to destroy Frank and Lu’s partnership. Unlike previous seasons, which leaned on self-contained mysteries, this season has a serialized thread tying the episodes together.
This means higher stakes, more emotional payoff, and a reason for viewers to binge every episode instead of dipping in and out. If successful, it could elevate the show from a “cozy watch” to a must-follow drama.
Conclusion: The Case That Changes Everything?
As Shakespeare & Hathaway returns on September 24 at 8 p.m. on U&alibi, expectations are sky-high. For some, it will always be a comforting escape, a gentle detective drama with Shakespearean nods and quaint English backdrops. But for others, Season 5 might just be the moment the show graduates from cult favorite to mainstream heavyweight.
The question now isn’t whether Frank and Lu will solve their latest mysteries. It’s whether this scrappy, addictive series can finally claim its place alongside Midsomer Murders, Endeavour, and the greats of British detective television.
And judging by the buzz, the fans already have their verdict: guilty… of being completely binge-worthy.