British detective dramas have always had a loyal following, but few recent series have managed to carve out as distinctive a niche as the one led by Jo Joyner and Mark Benton. Now back for its fifth season, this Stratford-upon-Avon–set mystery continues to build on the addictive blend of charm, wit, and crime-solving that has made it a fan favorite since its 2018 debut.
What sets this series apart from its peers is the unlikely partnership at its heart. Joyner and Benton strike a perfect balance as mismatched private detectives: she sharp, intuitive, and pragmatic; he more laid-back, occasionally bumbling, but quietly insightful. Their chemistry makes every case feel alive, whether they’re chasing down small-town scandals or unearthing more sinister secrets. It’s a partnership that brings both humor and humanity to each episode.
The fifth season wastes no time reminding viewers why the show has earned such praise. On the surface, the mysteries carry the same comforting appeal of classic British “cosy crime” dramas — picturesque settings, eccentric suspects, and a community teeming with secrets. But dig deeper and there’s an undeniable sharpness to the writing. The crimes often carry a darker weight than the lighthearted tone might suggest, tackling themes of betrayal, ambition, and moral compromise. This balance between cosy charm and genuine stakes is what makes the show so compulsively watchable.
Visually, the series leans into its Stratford setting, with every shot of the town contributing to the atmosphere — a place where Shakespeare’s legacy collides with the messy realities of modern life. That backdrop, combined with witty scripts and clever twists, elevates the drama beyond formula.
With an impressive 89% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, it’s no surprise that critics and audiences alike have embraced the show. Some fans even argue it’s become a worthy successor — or perhaps a rival — to the legendary Midsomer Murders. Where Midsomer thrives on eccentricity and longevity, this series feels fresher, more contemporary, and a little more self-aware.
Season 5 doesn’t reinvent the wheel, but it doesn’t need to. Instead, it leans into everything that made the first four seasons a success: sharp character dynamics, clever mysteries, and a tone that manages to be both cosy and cutting. For fans of detective dramas, this return is not just welcome — it’s essential viewing.