The Great Gatsby (1974) – Drama/Romance
When Robert Redford took on the role of Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby (1974), the casting became an event in itself. F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel was already a literary classic, and expectations were sky-high. Yet Redford initially hesitated. He feared Gatsby might appear too shallow on screen—just a wealthy man hiding behind champagne and glittering soirées. For Redford, the essence of Gatsby was not glamour but secrecy, longing, and profound loneliness. He only agreed after making sure the character’s “outsider” quality would remain at the heart of the film.
Director Jack Clayton and producer David Merrick, eager to secure Redford, granted many of his requests. One of the most significant was involving Ralph Lauren to design Gatsby’s wardrobe. Redford wanted the costumes to reflect both elegance and restraint, something timeless rather than flashy. Lauren later remarked that Redford embodied Gatsby perfectly—handsome, distant, yet brimming with unspoken yearning.
A striking example of Redford’s approach came during the filming of the novel’s famous party scenes. While hundreds of extras filled the set with laughter, music, and champagne, Redford deliberately stood apart, watching from a balcony until his cue. Afterward, when asked why he didn’t mingle, he explained, “That’s Gatsby. He throws the party, but he’s never really in it.” The choice thrilled Clayton and became a defining aspect of Redford’s performance.
Though the film itself received mixed reviews, Redford’s interpretation gave Gatsby the haunting aura Fitzgerald described—a man dazzling on the surface yet profoundly isolated inside. For Redford, the role resonated on a personal level. It mirrored his own complicated relationship with fame, where adoration and success often masked a quiet sense of solitude.
Word count: 302